Childrens Court bail

For legal aid to be granted for an application for bail in the Childrens Court the following tests must be satisfied:

• the applicant meets the means test, and
• the applicant meets guideline 6 – bail, and
• the applicant meets the merit test, and
• the applicant has been provided funding for the substantive matter, and
• the application for bail is not able to be made at the next mention, and
• the applicant is in a show cause situation and/or the prosecution has advised of their intention to oppose bail.

Documentary requirements

Application or request for an extension of aid received from client

Applicants seeking a grant of legal assistance should forward all of the following documents for assessment:

• A completed and signed Legal Aid Queensland application form, if applicable
• Proof of income and assets (refer to the means test)
• A copy of the applicants criminal history and/or traffic record.

Application or request for an extension of aid received from preferred supplier or in-house practitioner

Preferred suppliers seeking a grant of legal assistance should electronically submit an application for aid or extension request via the Grants Online system along with the appropriate information request or checklist. The following documents are retained on file:

• A completed and signed Legal Aid Queensland application form if applicable
• Proof of income and assets (refer to the means test)
• All documentation as outlined in part A4 of the case management standards - criminal law.

Interpretation

There is a strong likelihood of bail being granted

Legal Aid Queensland regards that there is a strong likelihood of bail being granted when an experienced practitioner would consider it likely that a magistrate could grant bail.

The practitioner must take all the evidence and circumstances of the case into account and the chance of bail being granted must be real and not fanciful. This requires much more than an arguable case.

Legal Aid Queensland will consider the following factors which may have a bearing on an applicants likelihood of bail being granted:

• age of the applicant
• seriousness of the offence
• previous breaches of bail (including failures to appear)
• previous breaches of probation (including prison escapes)
• ties with Queensland
• show cause (reverse onus) (section 16)
• availability of accommodation
• availability and amount of surety
• previous juvenile and adult criminal history
• opposition from crown
• next date for court
• strength of the prosecution case
• pandemic response

CoVID 19 Pandemic response considerations:

1. Delay in hearing date

The current response will have a very significant impact on delay in the listing (or relisting) of a hearing and as time goes on the backlog will grow.  In these circumstances there is a real risk that some people in custody, who already had a trial listed, will possibly be waiting beyond six months for their trial.

A further consideration here is that even if they were ultimately convicted, they may have served presentence custody well beyond what they would ordinarily have been given on sentence.

2. Vulnerability of prisoners

There are a significant number of prisoners held in correctional facilities across Queensland.  Some facilities are reported as already at capacity. 

There are concerns that an outbreak in a correctional facility may create a significant health crisis. There are no particular age restrictions associated with current community restrictions and the age of inmates is not necessarily an indicator of lower risk. 

The vulnerability of prisoners is of a very high order.  Some prisoners will automatically fall into higher risk categories for example due to Aboriginal and Torres Strait islander heritage or chronic illness.

3. Current prison conditions

Current prison conditions are significantly more arduous than before. It is reported that there are no contact visits, severe restrictions on prisoner movement which is akin to being placed in solitary confinement.

The merit review for legal aid funding of bail applications should now incorporate the above considerations.

Whether someone has done enough time will be always be the subject of debate and the lawyer should provide advice that indicates they have turned their mind to the relevant aspects. 

For example:

• Bail is still likely to be a very poor prospect for murder or where the alleged offending is so serious that a long prison sentence is inevitable if convicted.

• Exceptions may be where the Crown case is considered weak or if the accused is elderly or has health complications that makes them particularly vulnerable in the current circumstances.

• In all other circumstances a detailed rationale will be required.

If relying on the first consideration above the solicitor should provide information detailing why there is a risk of the prisoner serving more time than they might expect on sentence.

Considerations 2 and 3 above are accepted by the courts at the moment.

Court responses

As this is an evolving situation, court responses to these issues are being monitored.

• The Courts in Queensland and interstate are recognising these 3 factors, which combined are significant.

• The Courts are acknowledging there is such a high level of uncertainty about when things might return to normal.

• Supreme Court of Queensland reasons for decision of Davis J

• Re JMT [2020] QSC 72

• Some relevant interstate decisions are as follows:

  • Rakielbakhour v DPP [2020] NSWCC 31/3/2020 Hamill J

  • R v Broes [2020] VSC 128

The applicant is in a show cause situation

A show cause situation is defined in section 16 of the Bail Act 1980.

Grant(s) of aid

The grant of aid for a bail application in the Childrens Court is C9.

Review of decisions

A decision to refuse legal aid for this type of matter may be appealed to the external review officer (refer to review of decisions).